So, you’ve heard the hype. AI can build an app for you, saving you countless hours of coding. It sounds tempting, right? But before you hand over your project to a large language model, let’s talk about the reality. Based on my experience, while AI is an incredibly powerful tool, it’s not a magic bullet. The results can often be more frustrating than fruitful.

The Allure and the Letdown

We all want a shortcut to a finished product, and AI seems to offer just that. The idea is simple: describe the app you want, and AI writes the code. In theory, you get a quick prototype or even a complete app.

In practice, however, the process is far from perfect. While AI can certainly generate code, it’s often an 80% solution, never 100%. This is where the real work begins—and the headaches.

What Can Go Wrong? The Common Pitfalls

I’ve encountered a number of issues when trying to build apps with AI. They’re not dealbreakers, but they are a constant reminder that AI is a tool, not a developer.

  • Reintroducing Bugs: You fix a bug, and later, the AI might reintroduce it in a different part of the code. This can lead to a frustrating “bug loop” where you’re constantly fixing the same issue.
  • Corrupted or Missing Translations: AI can struggle with nuanced language, leading to corrupted or entirely missing text in your app’s localization files. This can be particularly frustrating for apps intended for a global audience.
  • Unfinished Work: The AI might stop mid-task, leaving you with incomplete code or a half-finished feature.
  • Unintelligible Code: The code generated might be functional but not well-structured or easy to understand. This makes it difficult for you to debug or modify it later on.
  • Visual Inconsistencies: I’ve seen AI replace custom icons with generic Material Design ones, completely ignoring the design brief.
  • Repetitive Fixes: You might find yourself having to fix the same error repeatedly across multiple files.

AI Integration: Not All Tools Are Created Equal

The effectiveness of AI also depends heavily on the specific tool and its integration. Some AIs are far better at certain tasks than others.

  • GitHub Copilot: I’ve found GitHub Copilot integrated within VS Code to be excellent. Its contextual understanding of the code you’re writing is strong, and it provides relevant, in-line suggestions. It’s a fantastic pair programmer.
  • Claude‘s Strengths: In my experience, Claude’s integration is less seamless—it doesn’t have the same context-aware menus as Copilot. However, its output for app logic can be superior. For example, a 3×3 sliding puzzle game that failed to work with ChatGPT was successfully built using Claude.
  • ChatGPT‘s Limitations: While great for a lot of things, ChatGPT struggled with the sliding puzzle game. It couldn’t properly handle the image slicing needed for the tiles. Claude got it right, but the cuts were never exact. Both AIs fell short on that particular visual task, highlighting a common limitation.
VS Code with Claude AI

The Need for Speed: A Quick Note on Translation

When it comes to simpler, isolated tasks like translation, the speed and accuracy of different AIs vary. Gemini has been the fastest and most straightforward for me. Claude takes a long time, and ChatGPT seemed to give up on complex translation tasks rather quickly.

The Verdict: A Powerful Assistant, Not a Replacement

So, can AI build your app? The answer is a qualified “yes, but…”

Think of AI as a highly skilled but somewhat unreliable junior developer. It can write code quickly and handle repetitive tasks, but it lacks the critical thinking, attention to detail, and a full understanding of the project’s big picture. The AI will get you 80% of the way there, but the last 20%—the crucial work of debugging, refining, and ensuring quality—is all on you.

The most effective approach is to use AI as a powerful assistant. Let it handle the boilerplate code and initial drafts, and then you step in to guide, correct, and complete the work. It’s not about letting AI build your app; it’s about using AI to help you build your app faster and more efficiently.

Read more